Should Impact Factor be the standard for judging how sound a journal is?
Impact Factor is about citations and not necessarily quality
Post an Answer
Sign In to Answer
12 Answers
Qin
No, the impact factor only reflects the number of citations and is not equivalent to content quality; High quality papers may also be published in low impact factor journals, while low-quality papers may also be published in high impact factor journals.
Harri Merisaari
Soundness of journal is to be judged case-by-case per article, as citations which are used in calculating impact factor, may also be due to critique towards published papers, and not always to be considered as acknowledging soundness. Impact factor may be used as guide but not a standard.
Chong
No. Impact factor should be a guide but not a standard in judging the journal. You can have a very good paper submitted in low impact journal, and an mediocre in high impact impact journal.
Bob Sonawane
The impact factor of a journal is one of the major considerations about the scientific quality , value of unbiased independent nature and it's direct or potential impact or magnitude to advance scientific knowledge based on soundness findings.
Maria Marta Facchinetti
In my opinion, the impact factor (IF) should be used with caution when assesing the quality of a journal or the quality of an article, as it mostly reflects the amount of citations the journal has rather than the quality of the article or the quality of the journal. In the case of journals that are open access (predatory journals are included), they obtain better IFs because the readers can download the articles easily and thus, they have more visualizations and more citations. Moreover, nowadays there are more open access journals than a few years ago. In my experience, prestigious journals that have not accepted the "open access only" policy are having reduced IF than others. Furthermore, the scientific comunity is helping the editorials make a lot of money.
Adama Pamba Séré
No, the impact factor should not be the main criterion. This is an average of the journal’s citations, not a measure of an article’s quality. I have published in journals with and without impact factors. The rigor of peer review I saw did not depend on this figure. The transparency of evaluation, the clarity of methods, the availability of data, compliance with COPE rules, indexing (Scopus, DOAJ). In West Africa, many researchers publish in serious regional journals that have no impact factor.
Dr. Liu
Not exactly. It is true that the impact factor of a peer-reviewed journal inflect to some extent the quality and popularity of the journal. However, the impact factor value is influenced by a couple of factors. For example, (1) Whether the journal is subject to Open Access has a substantial impact on IF value, where open accessible journals tend to be cited more frequently; (2) The scientific scope of a journal is also an important determinant of its IF value, particularly, some manuscripts may be submitted to and published by journals covering multiple sub-divisions of science and technology, or by very specialized journals, the former generally have higher impact factors.
Dr. Sudipta Chattopadhyay
Never. With the impact factor, quality of paper/innovation can't be judged.
Beliu
No. The impact factor indicates relevance in the field, but that does not guarantee that all published articles are of high quality.
Olabisi
Impact factor should not be used to judge the quality of a journal. Most high impact journals are beyond the reach of academics in LMIC. So they are compelled to publish in institutinal based or professional organisations journals.
Thotanolla Surya Prakash
impact factor does give us a idea of how standard the journal is, based on that journal are classified into quartiles, its always great achievement to get into Q1 journals and its quiet tough too for beginners. being said that even Q2 and Q3 journal publishing is not that easy sometimes everything depends on the journal policies and requirements.
Dr Abdul Malik Khokhar