6
SciPoll 637: Crowd Sourcing of Publication Review
How many years of experience do you have? Grouped By What level of compensation would you require to perform a quick critical review of a publication in your area of expertise within 1 day?
Results
(731 Answers)
Answer Explanations
- > 40user-907425PhD in 1959.
- > 40user-847559See above a check my CV
- 10 - 20user-441980
- 30 - 40user-315553I have been reviewing articles, grants, promotion applications and other materials for over 30 years.
- 30 - 40user-377267I'm a professor of toxicology with40 years professional experience.
- > 40user-542548> 40 years from PhD.
- 5-10user-57242Been peer reviewing for the last five years
- 20 - 30user-786434I have reviewed papers since the nineties
- 10 - 20user-653585Academic and clinical work experience
- 20 - 30user-11344425 years since my first peer reviewed publication
- 20 - 30user-3311718 years in permanent faculty positions together with ca 8 hours of postdoctoral experience.
- 30 - 40user-38414I don't consider adequate to superficially evaluate a paper in 1- 2 hours. This time would allow only to check language and structure of a manuscript. A careful assessment demands checking graphs, references adequacy, figures, statistics, literature updating, reasoning, protocol fitness, etc.
- 20 - 30user-287804I started being invited to peer review papers shortly after my postdoctoral years.
- > 40user-669412All aspects of drug discovery and development, and medical affairs.
- 30 - 40user-138963Internal Medicina resident program (5y) after Medical School (6y)
- 20 - 30user-412773I started my PhD in 1997, and since 2000 I have been publising quality papers within the biology and biomedicine disciplines. Now I am a PI and run my own group of research.
- 5-10user-348125I'm a senior researcher who completed Ph.D. 9 years ago and has been working in the same field.
- 10 - 20user-47534619 years since I finished medical school
- > 40user-8281721st degree earned in 1976.
- 5-10user-299419I am counting since I started reviewing for international journals.
- 20 - 30user-210113counting from beginning of PhD
- 30 - 40user-275661Over 30 years since getting my PhD.
- 20 - 30user-730942I obtained my PhD in 2003. Since then I been involved in developing autonomous research.
- 30 - 40user-598503I have reviewed more than 3000 research papers in the past 30 + years
- 10 - 20user-494980DVM - 2009. PhD -2014 DSc (habilitation) - 2019
- 30 - 40user-958657Sloan-Kettering 1976.
- 20 - 30user-386308I started scientific life twenty-three years ago. And I've been a researcher for over 15 years.
- > 40user-938667I have 55+ years of scientific experience including reviewing and editing manuscripts. I am a member of several scientific journal editorial boards.
- 30 - 40user-446741BSc in 1986, PhD in 1990 + 34 years in biomedical R&D
- 20 - 30user-549473I amndirector of research of exceptional class with more than 200 publications in top level journals including Science Pnas with 15000 citations and H index of 63 WOS
I created three startup that have obtained more than 3M€ financial supports - 30 - 40user-242774As a PhD, Board-Certified toxicologist I have worked in state government, larger, global industry (for most of my career) and in private consulting for approximately 32 years.
- 30 - 40user-474509I have been working in the research field for 38 years, touching different areas of research in fields of biochemistry, biotechnology, chemistry
- 30 - 40user-78071935 years in consulting along with 10 years teaching in my field.
- 5-10user-480270Because I started doing my research work in 2018 and began my professional career as a researcher in 2021.
- 5-10user-692996For the last 8 years I was working on that
- 10 - 20user-109201NA
- 30 - 40user-740731Forty years of research experience in interdisciplinary biology, especially in Ecology or Environment-related themes.
- 30 - 40user-169864Amounts are influenced by regional salaries
- 30 - 40user-105956I completed my PhD in 1985
- > 40user-774962see above explanation
- 10 - 20user-579540I have worked in my field for 16 years after graduation.
- 30 - 40user-697539Have extensive experience in writing and reviewing review papers for international journals of high impact
- > 40user-935064I did my first peer review in 1974.
- 20 - 30user-337025A lot of money and time were spent to aquire 30 years of experience and to can be a good reviewer:)
- 20 - 30user-86609I have been performing research in my field for approximately 22 years.
- 30 - 40user-496176
All my life until I retired and now I have been working at the Institute of Nuclear Physics of the Academy of Sciences and am engaged only in science and the development of radionuclides.
- 5-10user-126416I have a five year review experience for more than five reputable journals including BMC ,BMJ, PAMJ, Annals of Medicine and Surgery ,Cueus etc
I have adequate review experience from Institutional Review Boards (IRBs)
I a competent reviewer for all quantitative research, qualitative research, Clinical trials ,Scoping review, Systematic review and Meta-analysis - 10 - 20user-61732Start PhH till now (medical
Specialist) - 5-10user-660265I'm working as a scientist and academic teacher since 2015, and as a Assistant Professor since 2021.
- 10 - 20user-44669212 years of experience in AI, machine learning, computational neuroscience
- 30 - 40user-267969I've been conducting peer-reviews for 30+ years.
- 20 - 30user-841110Thirty years in academia and industry.
- 10 - 20user-881641I have been reviewing articles since 2007. I have review for many journals from many publishing houese. Some of which are:
1. Reviewer for European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry (Elsevier)2. Reviewer for Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry (Elsevier)3. Reviewer for Journal of Taibah University for Science (Elsevier)4. Reviewer for Arabian Journal of Chemistry (Elsevier)5. Reviewer for Biomedicine and Pharmacotherapy (Elsevier)6. Reviewer for Journal of Advanced Research (Elsevier)7. Reviewer for Journal of Heterocyclic Chemistry (John Wiley)8. Reviewer for Chinese Journal of Chemistry (John Wiley)9. Reviewer for Archive der Pharmazie (John Wiley)10. Reviewer for Research on Chemical Intermediates (Springer)11. Reviewer for ACS Combinatorial Science (ACS Publishing)12. Reviewer for ACS Omega (ACS Publishing)13. Reviewer for Chemical Papers (Springer)14. Reviewer for Heterocyclic Communications (De Gruyter, Poland)15. Reviewer for Green Chemistry Letters and Reviews (Taylor and Francis)16. Reviewer for Polycyclic Aromatic Compounds (Taylor & Francis)17. Reviewer for Molecules (MDPI Publishing)18. Reviewer for Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (Hindawi Publishing)19. Reviewer for Medicinal Chemistry (Bentham Science Publishers)20. Reviewer for Oriental Journal of Chemistry (Oriental Scientific Publishing)21. Reviewer for African Journal of Biotechnology (Academic Journal)22. Reviewer for Canadian Journal of Pure and Applied Science (SENRA)23. Reviewer for International Journal of Applied Research in Natural Product24. Reviewer for Brazilian Archives of Biology and Technology – BABT25. Reviewer for British Journal of Pharmaceutical Research (Science Domain)26. Reviewer for International Research Journal of Pure and Applied Chemistry (Science Domain Publishing)27. Reviewer for International Journal of Plant & Soil Science28. Reviewer for Nature and Science (Marsland Press, USA)29. Reviewer for Journal of the Chinese Chemical Society (John Wiley)30. Reviewer for Tropical Journal of Pharmaceutical Research (UNIBEN)31. Reviewer for ChemistrySelect (John Wiley) - 10 - 20user-125484I has been teaching at the University of Mosul since and I still currently employed there.
- 30 - 40user-589243Medicine is already prostituted enough to charge fees for reviewing clinical work. OK?
- 30 - 40user-753791I will complete 40 years in 2025 in active research career.
- 10 - 20user-37102118 years
- 10 - 20user-215705M.S. in 2014, PhD in 2018, worked since 2014 in varying capacities in academia and research
- > 40user-49719I got my PhD at 27 and I am 67. I am retired, but I still review papers and grant proposal. I am an experienced reviewer.
- 10 - 20user-567411Usually, this amount is sufficient to cover the process and encourage the reviewer.
- 20 - 30user-382369I obtained my PhD in 1998, after 5-year research. Then, I have performed a postdoc training at the University of Buenos Aires (1 years), followed by 4 years of posdoc at the Natiional Institutes of Health (USA). Then I became an investigator at Conicet, and a professor , in Argentina (2006 until now).
- > 40user-637348I started my research career since I obtained my Masters Degree in 1971
- 10 - 20user-732641On toxicology
- 30 - 40user-397052I am a Professor Emeritus at a major academic medical school, have served on numerous editorial boards, have served as an Editor in Chief of a major journal in the microbiological sciences, and have performed hundreds of manuscript reviews over my career. The current practice is not to provide compensation for reviewing articles but as people get so busy with their regular positions, finding reviewers and getting timely reviews can be a real challenge. I'd like to see a pilot study to see if providing compensation results in faster and more robust reviews, right now, there is no evidence for this that I'm aware of.
- 30 - 40user-51054730+ years of experience in semiconductor chips design and manufacturing with the industry leaders: GlobalFoundries (2010-2020); IBM, Motorola Labs.
Expert knowledge of semiconductor device physics, manufacturing processes, equipment and specialty materials - 10 - 20user-827851About 400 papers reviewed in 10 years
- 30 - 40user-966722I became MD in 1991 and then started with scientific work.
- > 40user-445218$250 per hour seems to be a reasonable charge. One of my auto mechanics charges $150 per hour.
I will do peer review for papers for nothing if the paper is focused on my areas of interest. This turns out to be very few papers. I work on EPA panels as a Special Government Employee as a public service for a little more than $50 per hour but I may reconsider that policy as I get older and time gets even more precious. - 30 - 40user-813332I have been in full-time research for 40 years and have considerable experience reviewing articles.
- 30 - 40user-78154Researcher since 1985-
- >5user-920951Less than 5 (not more than as it suggests!) I have completed 4 or 5 review in the last year and they are my first.
- > 40user-550886idem
- 20 - 30user-102269My first position in academia was in January 2004.
- > 40user-414626I am now retired but am still active as an Executive Editor of a journal and have reviewed countless papers over my career
- 10 - 20user-363225Started reviewing, editing and manuscript writing and publication since 2016, with several publication scholarly journals
- 5-10user-905834I have 5-10 years of experience and have reviewed for more than 30 international journals; to date, I have reviewed more than 100 papers.
- 30 - 40user-608413About 33 years of clinical practice with review of medical literature
- > 40user-642125I have been a licensed physician for over 40 years, a researcher for nearly 50 years, and have published hundreds of articles, chapters, books, and guidelines for the World Health Organization. I have been Editor-in-Chief of a journal for over 5 years.
- > 40user-754769He has conducted more than 40 peer reviews to date. We are doing our best to respond to all of them, but they require a lot of work.
I still believe that some form of remuneration is necessary. - 10 - 20user-77977114 years post PhD reviewing papers
- >5user-921148<5
- 20 - 30user-593019Medical doctor since 2001.
- 5-10user-108505Worked as a research Engineer for a private company (3 years)
Working as an assistant(then associate) professor for a University (6 years) - 30 - 40sab2xI have been in my area of expertise for a long time.
- 20 - 30user-901717I have thirty years of experience in Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics, and have published thirty articles. I also serve as an Editorial Board Member in "Current Drug Metabolism".
- 30 - 40user-861466experience as specialist physician, researcher, and full professor.
- 20 - 30user-676638I have a professional experience of 21 years. Since more than a decade, I am active as a reviewer and editor for many prestigious journals, and as a member of national/ international grant review panels.
- 20 - 30user-404672As above
- 10 - 20user-248213I have been working in research during 18 years.
- 5-10user-546254I have 2 years post doctoral experience and 3 years post PD as a researcher/academic in my field.
- 30 - 40user-138300Professor neuroscience and clinical science
- 10 - 20user-255626I have 14 years of experience in handling analytical instruments like Gas Chromatography, High performance Liquid Chromatography, Mass spectrometry. I am an expert in the field of Metabolomics and lipidomics.
- 5-10user-266855I have 17 years of experience in my role and ten years of reviewing experience along with 3 years acting as an academic editor.
- 5-10user-987379I have 6 years of experience reviewing manuscripts for a variety of journals, with a wide range of impact factors.
- 10 - 20user-437100Have in clinical science for the last 15 years
- 30 - 40user-200863I have extensive experience in toxicology, >30 years following my PhD and >40 years including professional work before going back to school for PhD.
- 20 - 30user-744452Expert in global health
- 20 - 30user-474161I have a PhD degree from Argentina in 1999 and was a post-doctoral student in the US between 2000 and 2006. I am now a Full Proffesor and Independent Reseacher in Argentina
- 30 - 40user-41956I am 78 years old and have vast experience advising industry and regulators, reviewing safety assessments and reports varying from 5 to 50 pages, and serving on panels that draft their findings, 25-100 page documents.
- 20 - 30user-156962Been in science and research for a long time.
- 10 - 20user-86421Almost 20 since I started in 2005
- 20 - 30user-43697Been a toxicologist since 1997
- 30 - 40user-639182That is my qualification, my work and indeed my life.
- 10 - 20user-101632got my first post phd job ~11 years ago
- 30 - 40user-852959I've been working as a professional scientist since my first career job in 1986. Although I wrote (and reviewed) papers as a student, I do not think that should be included in my estimated time of experience.
- user-797934Any review should be compensated especially with increase fees journal put on authors to publish plus there is a lack of motivation for review and this affects publication many author wait more than 6 months for their manuscripts to be reviewed
- 30 - 40user-813921I started working in 1989 as a professional board-certified analytical chemist
- 30 - 40user-600401I have published almost 400 peer reviewed articles and have benefited greatly from the peer review system. If we require compensation for everything we do in society, productivity will suffer due to the focus on financial transactions.
- 20 - 30user-28974I'm MD, MPH, MBA
- 20 - 30user-168151Eslecially on internal Medicine and diabetes.
- 5-10user-190861I finished my PhD in 2017 and have since worked as a postdoctoral researcher in the UK and China.
- > 40user-417588Based on my regular fees after 50 years experience
- 10 - 20user-345911Family doctor (4 years of clinical work to obtain the title in Spain after 6 university years and a complex exam for choosing speciality), and then another exam to obtain access to my Psychiatrist title, always preparing investigations based on a continuous clinical practice of my two titles, working hard in Addiction medicine, but not only this area, and also in a mixed public & private practice for some years, assisting new MIR of Psychiatry during guards (continued assistance in a laboral practice of 17/24 hours per day)
- 10 - 20user-59028220
- 10 - 20user-84775211 yrs
- 10 - 20user-634909I am a full professor in academia and have also worked as a scientist in the pharmaceutical and biotech industry. I have received federal and foundation grants, and continue to publish original research papers.
- >5user-8019123 years, just finished a PhD
- 10 - 20user-89626Experience of 14 years in research, publications, peer review, editing
- 10 - 20user-136424I've been active with scientific research since 2009
- 10 - 20user-89114812 years in academic field
- 10 - 20user-469485In my opinion, completing review process is a time bound manner with one week timeline is really requiring genuine efforts and may be provided compensation.
- 30 - 40user-667584I am retired since one year, but I have a strong experience of review for both original and review papers.
- 10 - 20user-997202I have more than ten years of experience in the area of conducting a research and reviewing a journal articles.
- 10 - 20user-15825I started in 2004 as a Research Assistant in a UK University, I did my PHD years later (fisnished in 2014), worked as a Postdoc for some years and now working as a Technical Research in a Government Institution
- 20 - 30user-917846I have been working at the university for 20 years and constantly review for different journals.
- 30 - 40user-245397I have been a reviewer for peer-review journals and grants since 1994.
- 5-10user-251614I have been working as a postdoctoral fellow or research scientist since 2016
- 20 - 30user-356107Although my first publications date back to 1989, my experience as a reviewer dates back to 2003.
- 20 - 30user-834001I have over 20 years of experience in both academia and industry.
- 10 - 20user-902950In academia since 2005 (PhD, post-doc, tenure track...)