Most definitely Maybe Overkill Total
Patients with known cardiac impairments 81.90% 86 17.14% 18 0.95% 1 105
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments 50.96% 53 42.31% 44 6.73% 7 104
Anyone over 70 yrs of age 41.35% 43 43.27% 45 15.38% 16 104
Anyone over 60 yrs of age 26.73% 27 41.58% 42 31.68% 32 101
Anyone over 50 years of age 17.65% 18 35.29% 36 47.06% 48 102
Everyone 9.00% 9 21.00% 21 70.00% 70 100

Answer Explanations 37

user-273449
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone001

Children would be overkill, however, grownups in general can benefit

user-933346
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

It is a multifunctional device, generally with high ergonomics, easy haptics and easy maintenance. Therefore, it is easy to adopt.

user-452756
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments001
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Technology is not sufficiently developed and interpretations might be problematic.

user-165049
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone100

There is no harm in wearing the device and it is a useful screening tool

user-646901
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone001

you need to start with a high-risk, high benefit population and segment accordingly. There will not be one solution for everybody but even this solution needs to be tailored individually with shared decision making between patient and physician

user-104260
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone001

high risk should be screened

user-346054
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age
Everyone001

High incidence of some arrhythmias at certain age

user-547683
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments001
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

It is difficult to select a population in whom routine smart watches usage would be of benefit to detect subclinical atrial fibrillation. Possibly, I would start investigating in a high-risk population with a high-likelihood of undiagnosed atrial fibrillation in whom the diagnosis would significantly change treatment, e.g. patients older than 60 years with dilated left atrium and a cerebrovascular event. This could improve the diagnosis of atril fibrillation in comparison to routine (e.g. 24h to 72h Holter monitoring, the latter not being routinely available for all patients in several hospitals).

user-698057
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

These devices can not be recommended before documented data

user-532952
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments001
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments001
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

I am over 70, with a heart condition. Expensive watch is in a drawer at home. Fingertip monitor is in my pocket. Card with emergency number is in my wallet. Cheap Cell phone has emergency number on it. Paper copy of latest ECG is also in my wallet.

user-932521
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

About 20% of people over 65 years have atrial fibrillation, one of many arrythymias, so aiming for over 60s makes sense.

user-441980
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

But proper orientation is to be provided.

user-623341
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

as above

DrAndyDABT
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

It should be an option for anyone, but it should only be recommended for those at high risk.

user-508906
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

This decision needs to be done by each person individually.
Permanent supervision of body performance will detect some critically issues but will in parallel produce a lot of awarness to normal abnormalities.

user-604552
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age
Anyone over 60 yrs of age
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone

These are the groups that cover the majority of fatal cardiac impairments. Especially in 50s many case aren't diagnosed and people are unaware of beeing in danger.

user-819042
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

This technology merged with smart watch can be used by everyone.

user-40527
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone

above 40 age required to wear

user-664651
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone100

Why not? It could save your life

user-125195
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

For the reasons I stated in my answer to the second question - to evaluate cardio fitness and stimulate exercise, diet and the like, to establish a baseline and monitor trends as well as to provide alerts should a cardio emergency be encountered

user-394368
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Screening sensitivity and specificity varies by age.

user-89655
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone001

Sudden cardiac failure at a younger age is rather sudden and wearing a smart watch may not make much of a difference. The cost/benefit ration may be too high for everyone to wear, but high risk and elderly would benefit the most.

user-694002
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone100

Wearing smart heart monitoring devices is becoming more important as new infections emerge and lifestyle changes predispose people to heart-related conditions or diseases.

user-320876
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments001
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

See explanation above.

user-38414
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Explained above i

user-622747
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age100
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone010

it can promote community health

user-85375
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

For those with SVT it may assist with monitoring, but accuracy of current tech is a limitation and will not capture QRS so will not replace holter monitoring.

user-998255
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments001
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Probably the worries it may cause outweighs the actual health benefits

user-885889
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Too much risk of false positive alerts for routine healthy monitoring

user-897569
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone001

Scientific evidence from studies.

user-786859
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

I think there is a very real risk of a false sense of security from these devices. If they are not specific medical devices designed for this purpose - I worry.

user-200863
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

Only once when they are proven to be reliable as specially designed equipment for this purpose. Until then it may give false positive or negative results, putting people at risk of rushing to ER (false positive) or ignoring the situation (false negative)

user-949839
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

the 70+ might be justified for fall detection, more than heart.

user-863919
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments010
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments010
Anyone over 70 yrs of age001
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

see above

user-487852
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age100
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age010
Everyone010

People should just be on the look out for their health

user-907789
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age001
Anyone over 50 years of age001
Everyone001

Patients with known cardiac impairments or family history of heart disease are at a much higher risk of sudden cardiac death

user-198903
Most definitelyMaybeOverkill
Patients with known cardiac impairments100
Patients with a family history of cardiac impairments100
Anyone over 70 yrs of age010
Anyone over 60 yrs of age010
Anyone over 50 years of age100
Everyone010

Medical and nursing students

Please log in to comment.