See my comments to the previous question 3.3. Based on the figure 5 of the whither paper, it might be that the real KMD (systemic dose nonlinearity) is rather observed between 10 and 20 ppm, not 20 ppm exactly. However, the reviewer agrees that it is close to 20 ppm (but might be 15 ppm). In the white paper, the assumed KMD of 30 ppm or below has been derived from the dataset on the ratios cis/trans of 1,3-D in blood. However, the figures 5 and 6 suggest a KMD closer to the 15 ppm range. Therefore, it is stated that doses ≥20 ppm would be expected to provide quantifiable levels of the cis-isomer (which might only be due to analytical limitations), which might explain an assumed higher KMD of 30 ppm. However, this does not mean that a non-linearity of the GSH depletion might not occur significantly below 30 ppm (e.g., 15 ppm) as observed in the Figures 5 and 6. More discussions should be presented on that aspect to explain why 30 ppm only has been chosen as the upper limit of the KMD versus potentially 15 ppm in the Figures 5 and 6.
Expert 12
04/17/2019 11:15The reviewer does not totally agree; based on figure 5 it could be that KMD=61 ppm, but based on figure 5 KMD could be lower than 20 ppm. One thing is for sure it is somewhere between 15 and 61 ppm
Expert 4
04/22/2019 10:35I agree with the points raised by reviewer 292467 [Expert 12] , but to me the overall picture supports a KMD of 20 or below
Expert 10
04/23/2019 10:27I agree that the overall picture support a KMD of 20 ppm or below (figure 5 of white paper).