4.6
SciPi 145: Peer review of the genotoxicity, toxicokinetics, and carcinogenicity of a pesticide
Is there a need to conduct any additional studies that could increase your level of confidence? (please explain)
Results
(4 Answers)
Answer Explanations 4
No
Expert 6
I don't think it is necessary to conduct any other study to increase my level of confidence.
No
Expert 9
Based on the extensive database for this compound, I would not recommend that additional studies be conducted.
No
Expert 5
If human exposure levels are well below extrapolated threshold doses, the there is no need. However, the additional tests described above would increase my confidence.
No
Expert 11
I do not think that an additional carcinogenicity study will clarify. Assessment of tumorigenic potential and relevance of the findings needs to integrate mode of action and toxicokinetics as done in the white paper. This should be sufficient for conclusions on potential carcinogenicity
Expert 11
04/18/2019 02:41Agreement here, even in case of negative results in a new study, the results of Scott et al require interpretation. The white paper does a good job addressing the issues