SciPi 145: Peer review of the genotoxicity, toxicokinetics, and carcinogenicity of a pesticide
Have you had any previous involvement with the document(s) under consideration including authorship, collaboration with the authors, or previous peer review functions? If so, please identify and describe that involvement.
Results
(13 Answers)
-
Expert 5
no
-
Expert 11
I have been working on halaogenated alkenes and their modes of action and know most people active in the area in person. Have not peer-reviewed this or collaborated on this issue.
-
Expert 7
No
-
Expert 9
No
-
Expert 12
No
-
Expert 2
Do you really mean to ask this (boilerplate?) question of this panel, given that the 2 documents we've been given so far provide NO author names? How can I answer this question? (but I'm confident the answer *would* be no...)
-
Expert 14
No
-
Expert 6
Never had any involvement with the documents under consideration here.
-
Expert 13
No
-
Expert 10
No
-
Expert 4
To my knowledge, no, but since the white paper is being reviewed anonymously I may have had previous involvement with one or more of the authors. To the best of my recollection I have not been involved in the assessment of 1,3-D or epichlorohydrin or any of the papers cited in the document. However, in the early- to mid-1980’s I did work for EPA’s Carcinogen Assessment Group, and I may have helped prepare portions of 1984 epichlorohydrin document cited. I may also have supervised staff working on 1,3-D while in the pesticide program or reviewed material prepared for it, but I have no recollection of doing so.
-
Expert 8
No involvement.
-
Expert 1
Did not have a look at the documents yet